Savior Siblings - 1071 Words

Savior Siblings The subject of savior siblings is a complex dilemma that encompasses multiple issues. Is it ethical to have a child in order to save another? Is pre-implantation genetic testing moral? Can parents make the decisions for their kids about organ donation? In order for this ethical dilemma to be resolved these questions need to be answered. In the case of Molly Nash, the family was not morally culpable for their decision to have another child to save Molly’s life because Adam was not born solely to save his sister’s life and because the methods used to save Mollys life had no adverse effects on Adam. Using preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) to obtain a healthy embryo to be used as a savior sibling raises the†¦show more content†¦In the case of savior siblings there is an important reason for using genetic screening that does not apply to designer babies– saving a child’s life. Therefore, the slippery slope argument fails to justify a ban on savior siblings because there are important differences between savior siblings and designer babies (Sheldon and Wilkinson, 2004). Nonetheless is important that the practice of PGD is properly regulated so that its abuse can be prevented. In the case of Molly Nash, PGD was ethically acceptable because it was done for the right reasons and had no negative consequences. The question of whether parents should be allowed to make decisions for their children about organ donation is difficult to answer. The family is normally responsible for making decisions for those who are judged too young or incompetent to do so, but should they be able to elect for organ donation while the person is still living? It is clear that in this specific case nothing serious was taken from Adam Nash to donate to his sister. Because the transplant did not directly affect him, his parents were justified in using his chord blood to save Molly’s life. However, the situation changes when parents w ish for their child to donate something more serious like bone marrow or aShow MoreRelatedThe Ethics Of A Savior Sibling Essay1403 Words   |  6 Pagestreat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means†. Critics of savior sibling have argued that the procedure violates this concept. They argue that there is something fundamentally wrong with parents having children for the wrong reasons. In the case of a savior sibling, the parents are acting unethically by having a child for the purpose of saving the life of a second child and not for the sake of the child beingRead MoreA Research Study On Savior Siblings : Children Who Are Conceived Through Selective Assisted Reproduction1685 Words   |  7 Pages For my research paper I am going to write about savior siblings. Savior siblings are children who are conceived through selective assisted reproduction as a potential source of organs or cells for an existing older sibling who has a serious medical condition. I was first interested in this topic when I watched the movie My Sister’s Keeper. My Sister’s Keeper is about a 10–year-old girl who decides to sue her parents after forcing her to donate her kidney to her sister who is dying of leukemia. MyRead MoreSibling Saviors : A Child Suffering From A Disease2058 Words   |  9 PagesSibling Saviors Suppose a parent has a child suffering from a disease that is slowly killing them, such as acute promyelocytic leukemia, APL, or types of severe anemia to give a general idea. Eventually, their kidneys are going to shut down and despite years of fighting, the only way to keep that child alive is having them hooked up to machines until their organs completely give out and they die or become comatosed, in a vegetative state. All therapies, tests, treatments, and options have been exhaustedRead MoreDonor Babies : Grace Of God Saviors Or Last Resort Recyclables1226 Words   |  5 PagesDonor Babies: Grace of God saviors or last resort recyclables â€Å"It made me wonder, thought, what would have happened if Kate had been healthy. Certainly, I would not be part of this family.† A quotation from the 2004 book My Sisters Keeper by Jodi Picoult. (My Sister s Keeper) A book about a girl who was born as a donor baby to help her sister not die. In the book Anna wants the rights to her body and goes to court to get them. Why shouldn’t she, how horrible would it be to have to always give aRead MoreMy sisters keeper ethical issues761 Words   |  4 PagesLeukemia at 2 years old. She has an older brother, Jesse, but he is not a genetic match for a bone marrow transplant and has never been able to forgive himself for that. Doctors suggested that her parents scientifically engineer another child â€Å" a Savior Sibling† to ensure a bone marrow match for Kate. Kate’s parents, Sara and Brian, eagerly pursued having another child through In vitro fertilization and Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis in order to tr y and save Kate’s life. From the moment Anna wasRead MoreWho Is Born Into Their Family?1702 Words   |  7 Pagesthe first group experience a child has and the child’s role in their family influences the development of the child’s individual personality traits. In families, children learn what is valuable and meaningful to their parents and siblings and they compete with their siblings for various roles before they find their personal niche in the family (Stewart et al., 2001). As children are socialized into their families, the children make a place for themselves and no two children make a place for themselvesRead MoreThe Novel Best Friend And Lorraine s Tale 1382 Words   |  6 Pagesus singletons will ever truly relate to. Imagine having a built-in best friend, as is the case with so many twin sets. Larry and Lorraine’s tale is no different. While they shared an extra 9 months together, and a few more years before the next sibling came, they were inseparable. Not identical, our Mother and Father did dress them in similar fashion and they were indeed each other’s best friend in life, even if it wasn’t always seen or understood. For sometimes the people that were closes withRead MoreThe First Child Of Seven Essay2168 Words   |  9 Pagesthat bad things would happen to me if I told. I believed them. Many times, they were my babysitters – the older adolescence in the home – when my mother and grandmother had to work and run errands. It was the norm to have the older siblings watch the younger siblings. My first perpetrator was my brother. Since then, he has been diag-nosed as mentally ill. His patriarchal side of the family had a known his-tory of mental illness. At the time he molested me, he was at least fifteen years old. He wouldRead MoreThe New Method Of The Creation Of Savior1645 Words   |  7 PagesCritics argue that permitting the creation of savior siblings through PGD is the first step down a slippery slope that ends with frivolous reasons for selecting an embryo over another. The procedure would open the door for parents to decide on specific characteristics of their babies. This is the creation of fully-fledged ‘designer babies’. As in the words of Josephine Quintavalle , â€Å"the new technique is a dangerous first step towards allowing parents to use embryo testing to choose other characteristicsRead MoreGenetically Altering An Unborn Child1467 Words   |  6 Pagesin vitro in order to create a savior sibling. Doctors can now create ways to save thei r patients through science, which can affect the lives of many. In the movie My Sisters Keeper, Anna, a genetically enhanced baby was created in order to save her sick sibling. Anna never got the opportunity to live her own life; instead she was there to simply protect her sister by undergoing various surgeries. It isn’t fair for the children that are born solely to be a â€Å"savior.† In today’s society, scientist